"Give Me a Clue!"

Bigger text (+)Smaller text (-)

"Give Me a Clue!"
by Elliott Wilcox

If you want to improve your jury selection skills, consider following the example set by the best doctors in your town.

Years ago, when I was looking for a new doctor, my Dad gave me some great advice: "Whatever you do, don't take health advice from a fat doctor, or from a doctor who smokes."  Not bad, huh? But in addition to looking for health care professionals who are actually healthy, here's another important tip: Find a doctor who knows how to ask questions.

The humorist  Will Rogers once said, "The best doctor in the world is the veterinarian.  He can't ask his patients what is the matter - he's got to just know."  Since you probably don't want to share the waiting room with a cocker spaniel, you'll want to choose someone who asks a few more questions.    The reason it's important is because the quality of your doctor's questions determines the level of care you'll receive. 

For example, let's say that you injure yourself while training for a beer pong tournament (No, really, it's a sport!  Check out this article in Time magazine!). Your elbow is killing you, so you visit the doctor who asks, "How does your elbow feel?" 

Unless you're incredibly articulate or well-versed in medical terminology, you probably won't do a very good job of describing what's wrong.  If your doctor isn't psychic, there's a good chance that he'll incorrectly diagnose the problem.  But a good doctor doesn't settle for vague, general answers.  Instead, he asks follow-up questions to pin down the problem: "Is the pain on the inside or the outside of the elbow?  Do you have pain when lifting objects?  Does the pain radiate down your forearm? Are you able to straighten or flex your arm?"

By asking you specific questions, he makes it easier for you to answer and provide him with the details he needs to correctly diagnose the problem ("I'm afraid you've got Tennis Elbow") and prescribe the appropriate treatment ("The only way you'll be able to represent your firm in next week's beer pong tournament is if you ice it and take a series of Cortisone injections.")

To improve your jury selection, apply the same technique to your questioning.

You know that your goal for jury selection is to get the jurors talking, because the more you get them to open up and talk about the issues that matter to your case, the more you'll learn about them and the more intelligently you'll exercise your peremptory strikes. You also know that one of the best techniques for getting jurors to talk is by asking open-ended questions, which prevent the jurors from giving you simple "Yes" or "No" responses.  Unfortunately, when most attorneys learn about this technique, they try asking completely open-ended questions, with terrible results like this:

Attorney: "What do you think about the presumption of innocence?"
Juror: "Um...  It's good?"

You can elicit better responses than this from your jurors during jury selection if you avoid asking questions that are too broad.  Instead, give them some guidance about how to answer.  Remember, jury selection is a new experience for most of your jurors.  Most of them aren't comfortable speaking in public, let alone answering questions frominquisitive trial lawyers.  To learn what they're thinking, it's your responsibility to make it easy for them to answer your questions.  They need your help, and they need you to guide them to the answer.

Rather than asking completely open ended questions ("How do you feel about the phrase, 'innocent until proven guilty'?"), ask for more specific information that drills down to the details you're looking for. Remember to frame your questions in an open-ended format, so that most of your questions begin with "Who," "What," "Where," "How," "When," "Why," "Explain," or "Tell us..." The most important point is to ensure that you don't ask for completely narrative answers, but instead, give the juror a little guidance so he has some idea of what he's expected to say.

Remember, the easier you make it for the jurors to talk to you, the more information they'll share with you.  The more they share, the more you'll learn about them, and the better your diagnosis will be when it comes time to decide whether or not to exercise a peremptory strike against them.

Editor's note: By the way, this technique doesn't just work in jury selection, it will also improve your direct examination.  By being more specific, you'll help your witnesses improve their testimony.  It's much easier for your witness to answer, "Who was the first person to notice a problem with the fetal heart monitor" than "Tell us, what happened next?"


The Secret to Spotting Favorable Jurors

Tips for Testifying  Tips for Testifying

Tips for Speech Evaluation  3 Tips for Speech Evaluation
The Art of Evaluation  The Art of Evaluation

Tips for Direct Examination  6 Tips for Direct Examination


NOTICE: Elliott Wilcox is not affiliated with Freedom School.
NOTICE: If anything in this presentation is found to be in error a good faith effort will be made to correct it in timely fashion upon notification.
       Specialty Areas

All the powers in the universe seem to favor the person who has confidence.
Share/Save/Bookmark Subscribe

More & Other Information - Resource Pages
Admiralty related itemsBelligerent Claimant
BondsAttention Signing the Constitution Away
Citizenship / nationality related itemsEducation
GraphicsHistory
Jerry KirkAware
JurisdictionLaw related items
Lewis MohrLuis Ewing
MoneyOath related items
Reading MaterialReading Room
StuffTax matters
Travel relatedTruth
 Video
NOTICE: The information on this page was brought to you by people who paid this website forward so that someone such as you might also profit by having access to it. If you care to do so also please feel encouraged to KEEP THIS SITE GOING by making a donation today. Thank you. Make donation with PayPal - it's fast, free and secure!


Freedom School is not affiliated with the links on this page - unless otherwise stated.

Freedom School information served for educational purposes only, no liability assumed for use.
The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice.
Freedom School does not consent to unlawful action.
Freedom School advocates and encourages one and all to adhere to, support and defend all law which is particularly applicable.
Information is intended for those men and women who are not "US CITIZENS" or "TAXPAYERS" - continued use, reference or citing indicates voluntary and informed compliance.

Freedom School is a free speech site and operation as there is no charge for things presented
this site relys on this memorandum and others in support of this philosophy and operation.
The noteworthy failure of the government or any alleged agency thereof to at any time rebut anything appearing on this website constitutes a legal admission of the fidelity and accuracy of the materials presented, which are offered in good faith and prepared as such by Freedom School and third parties affiliated or otherwise. If the government wants to assert that any of the religious and/or political statements that are not factual appearing on this website are in error, then they as the moving party have the burden of proof, and they must responsively meet that burden of proof under the Administrative Procedures Act 5 U.S.C. §556(d) and under the due process clauses found in the Fifth, Sixth, and Seventh Amendments to the national Constitution BEFORE there will be response to any summons, questions, or unsubstantiated and slanderous accusations. Attempts at calling presented claims "frivolous" without specifically rebutting the particular claim, or claims, deemed "frivolous" will be in deed be "frivolous" and prima facie evidence that shall be used accordingly. Hey guys, if anything on this site is found to be in error a good faith effort will be made to correct it in timely fashion upon notification.

Freedom-School.com site, the DVD, or work computers´ DMCA Policy

the Freedom-School.com site, the DVD, and/or work computers, make effort to be in compliance with 17 U.S.C. § 512 and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act ("DMCA"). It is our policy to respond to any infringement notices and take appropriate actions under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act ("DMCA") and other applicable intellectual property laws.

If your copyrighted material has been posted on the Freedom-School.com site, the DVD, or work computers, in other than fair use capacity or if links to your copyrighted material are returned through our search engine and you want the material removed, you must provide a written communication that details the information listed in the following section. Please be aware that you will be liable for damages (including costs and attorneys´ fees) if you misrepresent information listed on the site that is allegedly infringing on your alleged copyrights. We suggest that you may want to first contact competent legal assistance on this matter.

The following elements must be included in your copyright infringement claim:

* Provide evidence of the authorized person to act on behalf of the fully disclosed alleged owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed. Please notice that we generally do not deal with third parties.
* Provide sufficient contact information so that we may contact you. You must also include a valid email address.
* You must identify in sufficient detail the copyrighted work claimed to have been infringed and including at least one search term under which the material appears in Freedom-School.com search results.
* A statement that the complaining party has a good faith belief that use of the material in the manner complained of is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law.
* A statement that the information in the notification is accurate, and under penalty of perjury, that the complaining party is authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed.
* Must be signed by the authorized person to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly being infringed. (Proper ratification of commencement.)


Send the infringement notice via email to the postmaster at Freedom-School.com

Please allow 1-3 business days for an email response. Note that emailing your complaint to other parties such as our Internet Service Provider (ISP) or server host(s) will not expedite your request and may result in a delayed response due the complaint not being properly being filed.


Presentation CopyrightŠ 2007, 2016
All Rights Reserved

H O M E